Yes, I would accept it. Not sure what the club you've mention is looking for in the submissions, but I don't see anything wrong with these.
Don't let it get you depressed. I also belonged to clubs before they turned into groups and never had a decline. Now since they became a group, my work seems to be sub-par in their opion. I left one group and haven't looked back. The second group I just recently rejoined because someone had requested one of my deviations for their gallery. But, sure enough, not everything I submit is accepted. I don't let it get to me because they have accepted a few. I guess it just depends on their mood.
Here's what the admin team said: please note that we only want your best work and while you show some great talent, we think that there's still room for improvement. Look through our gallery to see what kind of deviations we accept. Please don't be offended!
Weel f-them my best u got to be kidden...I am not a school boy anymore...
Exactly! I can handle a few getting rejected, but when I've submitted my most popular deviations and it's not good enough for them, it makes me feel that "someone" is on a power trip over there. More deviations are being accepted now compared to when the club went to group (then, nothing was being accepted), so I'll stick around and see what happens.
I don't blame you, though, for leaving. I've left other groups for the exact same reason--I figure if you're not going to accept my work, why am I a member? There's one group that went from unlimited submissions to "submit to Favorites and we'll move your deviations if we like it". When they did that, suddenly my work wasn't good enough. So I stopped submitting and took them off my watch but stayed a member. Then, they started requesting my work now and then. So if I wasn't good enough for you to move my deviations from the Favorites to the regular gallery, why are you requesting my work?
I know how you feel, had that happen to me in a club I was in and they always had a lame reason for it so I left the club as I had 2 of their mods have a go at me over my work, they are not worth bothering with, just leave them, there is nothing wrong with your work